Chapter 1 - Introduction
In the winter of 1989, on Peterborough's community radio station, Trent Radio, I heard
Hildegard Westerkamp's Cricket Voice. I was transported into a world in which the song
of a single cricket reverberated and resonated in an expansive place, in a way that I had
never heard before. Moreover, I felt urged to compose. It was an odd sensation. I had
grown up listening to and playing a wide variety of music, and had always been drawn to
electroacoustic music (even though initially I didn't call it that) since first hearing it in
England at a very early age.1 I had heard the work of hundreds of composers, and had
never felt drawn to compose electroacoustic music before this. Yet now a powerful desire
to record sounds and work with them on tape caused me to go out, rent equipment, and
begin. Since then, I have discovered that, through her composition, teaching, and radio
work, Westerkamp has had a similar effect on other composers, and is a particular source
of inspiration to many women composers in Canada. I believe that this is due to the way
she approaches soundscape. In the liner notes to Westerkamp's recent CD,
Transformations, American composer Pauline Oliveros says:
One can journey with her sound to inner landscapes and find unexplored
openings in our sound souls. The experience of her music vibrates the
potential for change. Her compositions invite interaction a chance to
awaken to one's own creativity.2
In this dissertation, I consider the significance of Hildegard Westerkamp's work to current
scholarship in the area of feminist epistemology, and to contemporary electroacoustic music
in the genre of soundscape composition. I focus specifically on her receptive, dialogic
approach to particular places and their sonic, social, political and technological resonances.
The title of this dissertation, "Sounding Places," has several implications. It refers first to
Westerkamp's insistence on a way of working that I call sounding, referring to the
mariner's slow and careful navigation through unfamiliar waters, finding a channel through
invisible topography.3 Westerkamp takes time to listen to places in depth in order to
understand them, moving slowly and carefully through landscapes, listening to their
resonances. Sounding places is also a term to describe the pieces that she composes, which
explore the intricate sonic relationships of active environments, places that are sounding.
The title also points to the importance of the concept of place in my discussion: the places
where pieces are composed and performed, the mediated locations (such as radio shows or
CDs) where the pieces are heard, and the places evoked in the responses of listeners.
The phrase "situated conversations" in my subtitle refers both to Westerkamp's approach to
composition and to my method of analysis of her work. Donna Haraway writes:
Situated knowledges require that the object of knowledge be pictured as an
actor and agent, not a screen or a ground or a resource, never finally as
slave to the master that closes off the dialectic in his unique agency and
authorship of "objective" knowledge ... Accounts of a "real" world do not,
then, depend on a logic of "discovery" but on a power-charged social
relation of "conversation." (1991: 198)
Consideration of the power of social relations in the construction of knowledge is also
important in the work of Lorraine Code, who has developed a feminist epistemology that
approaches knowledge as a social construct produced and validated through critical
dialogue, engaged with the subjectivity of the knower. When I think of Westerkamp's
soundscape work, I hear conversations with active sound environments in specific places
in which she is always aware of her own position as recordist. My method of analysis of
her work makes evident the diverse conversations between composer and listeners,
composer and researcher, musical work as composed and as heard. In each of these
conversations, the actors are situated, emplaced.
But Code's ideas are more fundamental to my work even than this. This dissertation is in
many ways an exploration of the epistemic potential of friendship. In her discussion of the
importance of second persons to the construction of knowledge, Code in distinction
from feminist thinkers such as Sara Ruddick who suggest maternal thinking as a model
proposes friendship as an epistemic paradigm:
In place of asserting a "natural," "found" sisterhood, appeals to friendship's
epistemic dimension open up creative possibilities for achieving sound,
morally and politically informed alliances, in which sisterhood, as Biddy
Martin suggests, "is achieved, not assumed; it is based on affinities and
shared but not identical histories." Alice Walker's conception of the "rigors
of discernment" that such achievements demand; Hannah Arendt's
alignment of friendship with thinking, a considered thoughtfulness, mutual
respect her claim, for example, that "the dialogue of thought can be carried
out only among friends" counters traditional associations of women's
friendships with irrationality and triviality. At their best, women's
friendships promote forms of solidarity that "are grounded not in claims to
victimization but ... in the convergence of shared perspectives, shared
competencies and shared pleasures." (1991: 102-103)
In part, this dissertation explores how the growing friendship between Westerkamp and me
opens up creative possibilities for a sound alliance between us, and contributes to our
knowledge. This theme emerges throughout the dissertation, but most particularly in the
methodologies chapter, the chapter on soundwalking, the chapter on Moments of Laughter,
and in the conclusions, where I discuss some of the dimensions of this continuing
dialogue. This is a friendship that began with my curiosity about her work, and extended
from there into many other areas of our lives. We have stayed at each others' homes,
shared intimate details about our life histories, our children have met, and we have walked
for miles together. She has trusted me to treat her and whatever knowledge she gives me
with respect, as she treats the inhabitants of the soundscapes that she works with in her
compositions.
Westerkamp's approach to composing is based on listening to the sounds of a place, and
using electronic means to subtly highlight the voices of that place, drawing attention to its
sonic specificities and musicalities. Because of Westerkamp's insistence on the specificity
of places, it is important to consider current scholarship about place and music. Chapter
Two begins with a discussion of the importance of the concepts "absolute" and "program"
as they affect contemporary composers' approaches to place in music. I consider these
concepts in light of current critical anthropological and geographical constructions of place.
In Western concert music, place has been considered important in relation to the musical
societies or repertoires of a location. The physical effect of the sound environment and its
significance to the compositional approaches of concert music composers has been
discussed only rarely until recently, and traditionally has been considered an extramusical
concern. For instance, the title of a thesis on environmental references in the work of R.
Murray Schafer is called "Extramusical References in the Works of R. Murray Schafer"
(Bradley 1983, my emphasis). Some recent publications about concert music, most notably
The Place of Music (Leyshon, Matless and Revill 1998), are beginning to consider the
influence of place in the compositional practices of certain composers. My discussion of
Westerkamp's approach to place contributes to this literature.
Although some composers have succeeded in creating evocative images of places using
acoustic instruments,4 tape recording has allowed electroacoustic composers to work with
the actual sounds of places. Still, there has been very little writing until recently in this field
about approaches to place. Among more recent examples, Trevor Wishart discusses the use
of landscape in electroacoustic music. His focus is on the generalizable, symbolic
properties of landscapes, not on the acoustic distinctions and relations among specific
landscapes, and their relationships with social, political and geographical contexts. In his
discussion of his work Red Bird, he generalizes the morphology of landscapes in order to
create a symbolic virtual landscape that mimics the spatial qualities of real landscapes,
without being closely related to any particular one. Wishart thinks of the sounds in Red
Bird as symbols, and associations of meaning are derived from juxtapositions and gradual
transformations between sounds that are not related to existing places:
The transformations [of sounds] are neither simply relatable to existing
acoustic spaces, nor do they relate to any conceivable or visualizable events
in the real world ... we find ourselves travelling in a dream landscape which
has its own logic." (1986: 52)
While Westerkamp considers the symbolic meaning of landscapes in her work, this is not
the main focus. She maintains links with events in the real world throughout her play with
the boundaries between dream and reality. Her discussions of her work focus on the
particularity of places, and her situated perspective as recordist:
... the recordist's position and perspective, the physical, psychological,
political and cultural stance shaping the choices when recording. My choices
are influenced by an understanding of the sonic environment as an intimate
reflection of the social, technological and natural conditions of the area.
(Westerkamp 1994: 89)5
The logic of Westerkamp's compositions is a logic derived from conversations with the
sound environment, a logic that reflects her experience of that environment: its
transformations within her imaginary always shift and return to the outside world, echoing
in a slightly different way each time.
Westerkamp's approach to place in soundscape composition has certainly been affected by
her association with the World Soundscape Project (WSP) in Vancouver in the 1970s. The
work of the WSP has received little mention in scholarly work about electroacoustic
composition. As I discuss in my Master's thesis on the work of Canadian women
composers of electroacoustic music (McCartney 1994: 15-17), there has been little said in
international academic literature about the development of electroacoustic music in Canada
as a whole, despite Canada's important contributions in acoustic ecology,6 musique
acousmatique, and sound environments in virtual reality. Some international authors do not
mention Canadian work at all, while others briefly discuss work at the University of
Toronto studio, or early work by Hugh Le Caine at the National Research Council in
Ottawa. Canada has generally been perceived as marginal to electroacoustic activity, with
most of the literature concentrated on developments in Europe and the United States.
The compositional work done by members of the World Soundscape Project (WSP) at
Simon Fraser University in the 1970s is not mentioned at all in texts devoted to
electroacoustic composition, perhaps because the project primarily emphasized research and
education about the soundscape. On the other hand, they have been very productive and
have published widely in the fields of music education,7 communications,8 radio art,9 and
acoustic ecology.10 Most of the project members were composers, including Westerkamp,
R. Murray Schafer (who directed the project), Barry Truax, Peter Huse, Bruce Davis, and
Howard Broomfield. All of these composers produced musical works as a result of their
association with the WSP. The only time that these works have been discussed in texts on
contemporary electroacoustic composition is in recent writings by Barry Truax.11 This
dissertation will contribute to the literature on electroacoustic composition in its detailed
discussion of the electroacoustic compositions of Hildegard Westerkamp.
The second part of Chapter Two continues the discussion of place in music by focusing on
Canadian music. I refer to contemporary Canadian literary, art, and musicological theory in
my discussion of the idea of Canada as a place within concert music of the last century,
how some Canadian concert composers deal with places within Canada, and how their
ideas of place have interacted with current international conceptions of what Canada is.
This section situates Westerkamp's work within the Canadian concert and electroacoustic
music communities. I also differentiate the generalized myths that characterize nationalist
music from music that refers to specific places, considering also how associations with
current conceptions of the "true North" can affect a composer's canonicity and acceptance
in the national and international communities.
Soundscape composition as a genre has remained relatively marginalized within the field of
electroacoustic music. In Chapter Three, I focus on the development of contemporary
soundscape composition, its lack of canonical acceptance within the field of electroacoustic
music, and the epistemological significance of its positioning within this field, using
feminist epistemology as a critical lens. I discuss definitions of electroacoustic music, and
the categorization of the field in several electroacoustic textbooks, focusing particularly on
how tape music, and more specifically soundscape music, is represented. I then examine
the dialogues among several composers (Pierre Schaeffer, Karlheinz Stockhausen, John
Cage, and Pierre Boulez) who influenced thought about electroacoustic composition in the
late 1940s and 1950s, at the time when the first studios began to be established. Finally, I
discuss two women composers, one whose influence was circumscribed by her isolation
(Daphne Oram), and one who has influenced Westerkamp's work (Pauline Oliveros), and
end with an investigation of Westerkamp's thinking. I discuss how the canonical positions
of these composers, or their failure to achieve canonical status within the field of
electroacoustic music, is related to their acceptance of assumptions that structure the genre.
One of the assumptions that has structured conventions of tape music is the idea of the
isolated "sound object" [objet sonore] originated by Pierre Schaeffer. Soundscape
composition considers sounds in relation to each other, in relation to listeners, and as
intrinsic sound objects. Barry Truax describes this contextual approach as concerned with
listeners' experiences and associations with sounds.
In the soundscape composition ... it is precisely the environmental context
that is preserved, enhanced and exploited by the composer. The listener's
past experience, associations, and patterns of soundscape perception are
called upon by the composer and thereby integrated within the
compositional strategy. Part of the composer's intent may also be to
enhance the listener's awareness of environmental sound. (Truax 1984:
207)
Truax focuses primarily on the relationship between composer and listener, in which the
composer calls on and integrates the listener's sonic associations. Awareness of the sonic
environment is a secondary intent in his description, partial and possible. Hildegard
Westerkamp describes an ongoing interaction in which the environment is central. "The
word soundscape always implies interaction between environment and individual, and
between environment and community" (Westerkamp 1988: 3). This contextual approach of
soundscape composition is often undervalued or misunderstood in the field of
electroacoustic music which values skillful manipulation of isolated sounds as abstractions,
following the traditions of musique concr‰te 12 and elektronische Musik.13
Recent work in feminist musicology questions the basis of values in musical communities
using insights about the relationships between power and knowledge derived from the
work of feminist epistemologists, including the analysis of such gendered dichotomies as
the culture-nature and abstract-concrete pairs, and their relationship to canonical issues.14
This dissertation extends those insights to a consideration of the epistemological bases of
musical values in the field of electroacoustic music, specifically focusing on the position of
soundscape composition in relation to the electroacoustic canon. My emphasis in this
chapter on the writings and musical works of several important composers in the field
facilitates a discussion of their particular approaches, and of how they reflect, express, and
contest these epistemological roots through their work.
Westerkamp has developed a way of working in which she constantly questions her own
position as composer, recordist, presenter, and listener. Her Master of Arts in
Communications at Simon Fraser University was a critical examination of her own life
history as it shaped her musical experience, as was the performance piece Breathing Room
3, written in 1991. Chapter Four is a biography that takes these works as a starting point,
then continues to the present day, documenting Westerkamp's life and work, and showing
how her various roles as composer, radio artist, educator, acoustic ecology activist and
mother have intersected in her work. Many of Westerkamp's earlier pieces were composed
specifically for radio, produced as a program series called "Soundwalking" on Vancouver
Cooperative Radio in 1978-79, based on the soundscapes of various places in the
Vancouver area, heard as she walked through and recorded them. She later took part in the
"Radio Rethink" project at the Banff Centre for the Arts. The pieces that she created for
these projects ride the borders between narrative documentary and musical discourse,
between broadcasting and listening.
In her teaching at Simon Fraser University, Westerkamp has encouraged students to think
of the filtering and sound processing capabilities of their own bodies, and their bodily
relationships with technology and with the sound environment. Her work as a founding
member of the World Forum for Acoustic Ecology has combined editorial and educational
roles with composition and research. Most recently, she has led workshops in Vancouver,
India, Japan and Brazil that integrate education and acoustic research with group and
individual composition by local and international composers. A discussion of her life and
work therefore contributes to thinking about music technology, education and acoustic
research as well as contemporary composition, suggesting an approach which integrates
these disciplines rather than delineating them.
In Chapter Five I discuss the analytical methods that I use to approach Westerkamp's
work. Electroacoustic music has defied traditional methods of analysis that rely on scores,
because they rarely exist in this genre. My approach brings together critical and feminist
theory with James Tenney's gestalt approach to musical analysis, and a wide range of
listener responses, to discuss the music in context. While work with listener responses is
fairly well developed in the analysis of popular music and in ethnomusicological projects, it
has not received as much attention in the analysis of contemporary Western concert works.
There are very few analytical projects in electroacoustic music that refer to listener
responses, and those that do exist tend to cite responses en masse, without specific quotes
or discussion of the relative authority of different listeners. My project contributes to
reception studies in its focus on bringing the responses of listeners from varied listening
backgrounds directly into the discussion of the music, as well as considering relationships
between these responses and the gestalt perceptual principles elaborated in Tenney's work.
This provides the means to discuss sonic, musical, social, and political issues that arise in
the works. While Westerkamp is interested in conveying a sense of place, each listener
constructs a different place15 depending on their own experiences and memories. My
method of analysis explores relationships among the perceptions and attitudes of listeners,
those of the researcher, and those of the composer.
I chose five works for analysis. Kits Beach Soundwalk is related to Westerkamp's
important work as a radio artist at Vancouver Cooperative Radio. Cricket Voice reflects
Westerkamp's ideas about wilderness and acoustic ecology. Moments of Laughter is an
example of a piece for live performance and tape, demonstrating her approach to the
performer, and to the relationship between performer and tape. It is also an exploration of
the musical importance to her of children's voices. I chose Breathing Room because this
short tape piece was intended to encapsulate her style. Finally, I focused on Gently
Penetrating Beneath the Sounding Surfaces of Another Place as representative of her recent
international work and her deep interest in the Indian soundscape.
In Chapter Six I discuss the importance of soundwalking to Westerkamp's association with
acoustic ecology, to her early compositional formation, as well as to her work as a radio
artist. Kits Beach Soundwalk is a concert piece that refers to Westerkamp's earlier
Soundwalking radio series. In August of 1997, I did a soundwalk with Westerkamp,
which took place in Queen Elizabeth Park, Vancouver, a location which is the subject of
her first article on soundwalking (Westerkamp 1974). Westerkamp recorded the
soundwalk, with both of us listening using headphones, while I photographed it. This
resulted in a website about the soundwalk, which includes discussions of listening
strategies, and the relationship of soundwalking to compositional practice. This is currently
online at .16
I also produced an interactive multimedia installation based on this soundwalk.17 In this
installation, I composed a number of short soundscape pieces from Westerkamp's initial
recording, using a compositional style similar to hers. While I have worked in soundscape
composition for some time, this particular experience was singular. I was working with
Westerkamp's recording, and was influenced by our conversation about the place, while
developing my own response to the soundwalk. The imagery associated with each musical
piece was developed based on listening to the soundwalk, and using the theoretical bases of
gestalt musical analysis. A description of the compositional process involved in the creation
of this work is included in Appendix G. These two multimedia projects gave me a chance
to engage further with the types of compositional processes that Westerkamp uses,
exploring this connection between us, while noting differences in our approaches, such as
my use of soundwalks as a more integral part of the compositional process, as well as my
preference for multimedia and online projects as a mode of presentation.18
In Chapter Seven, I analyze Cricket Voice, a wilderness piece which has been included on
two major electroacoustic anthologies. This is one of Westerkamp's more abstract works: it
does not include any spoken words, or live performance elements. Because of its
appearance on the anthologies, it was for many years one of her best-known works. It is
based on the night song of a single cricket, recorded in the Mexican Zone of Silence, a
desert area. It is a piece both about the cricket in the desert and about the urban person's
experience of desert: as a spacious and sparse environment that provides respite from the
crowded noise of the city, as an alien environment that may seem hostile, as a source of
spiritual strength. A particularly interesting group of listener responses to this work
imagined an alien species of giant crickets. I discuss these responses in relation to sound
design in contemporary science fiction film, particularly the movie Alien. Unlike the
majority of Canadian works that deal with the idea of wilderness, the environment of
Cricket Voice is neither a Canadian wilderness nor a northern environment. At the end of
this chapter, I compare Westerkamp's approach to Cricket Voice with Murray Schafer's
Princess of the Stars, specifically in relation to ideas about northernness, authenticity, and
technology.
Moments of Laughter, the subject of Chapter Eight, is a performance piece based on
Westerkamp's musical relationship with her daughter. I performed this piece myself as part
of the process of analyzing it. This piece raises really interesting questions about what
different people hear as music, and how this is related to what they believe should remain
private. Moments of Laughter transgresses the border between private and public, bringing
the sonic relationship between a mother and child into a public place, the concert hall. It
also raises many interesting questions about the shifting identities of mothers and children,
and how these are voiced, how they become stereotypes. Westerkamp based the piece on
recordings of her daughter's voice from birth to seven years, recordings begun by
Westerkamp and continued by her daughter once she was old enough to operate the
recorder. She derived the title of the piece from the work of Julia Kristeva, who describes
moments of laughter as the first times that a child recognizes others as distinct from herself:
unlike theorists who describe this realization in terms of existential angst, Kristeva argues
that the child feels joy on realizing that another is willing to provide pleasure and relief. She
further links this feeling of joy to creative urges:
Oral eroticism, the smile at the mother, and the first vocalizations are
contemporaneous ...
The inaugural sublimation ... brings us not only to the foundations
of narcissism ... but to the riant wellsprings of the imaginary. The
imaginary takes over from childhood laughter: it is a joy without words.
(1980: 283)
This quote indicates some of the transgressive issues raised by this piece: the association
of oral eroticism with motherhood and mother-child vocalizations is one that is repressed in
modern Western culture. The further association of early vocalizations with a wellspring of
creativity, a laughing imaginary built upon joy without words recognizes an importance in
the sounds of children rather than dismissing those sounds as "baby babble." The CD
ROM includes excerpts of Moments of Laughter linked to images produced by adolescent
girls as they listened to it, and score excerpts that indicate the relationship between tape part
and performer.
In Chapter Nine, I analyze Breathing Room, a miniature intended to reflect Westerkamp's
overall style, which she created for an anthology of short electroacoustic works.19 I
interpret Breathing Room as a representation of a cyborg body, using Donna Haraway's
image of the ironic cyborg, part organic and part cybernetic, an image which is "about the
tension of holding incompatible things together because both or all are necessary and true"
(1991: 149). Westerkamp's Breathing Room is structured around the breath: lying in the
studio, she metaphorically breathes in a variety of recorded sounds birds, water, insects,
machines impelled by a mechanical heart, sonically reflecting her ambivalent feelings
about technology, maintaining throughout a tension between heart and breath that never
resolves.
In Chapter Ten, I analyze Gently Penetrating Beneath the Sounding Surfaces of Another
Place, which is representative of Westerkamp's current international work.20 In recent
years, Westerkamp has been invited to several international locations to lead soundscape
workshops: in Japan, Brazil, Israel and India. She has visited India most frequently, and
Gently Penetrating... as well as the India Sound Journals are based on her experiences of
sound in New Delhi. In this work, she places herself in a position which is in some ways
similar to, yet in other ways different from her position when she produced the
Soundwalking series, years earlier: similar in that she is a newcomer to the culture,
different in that she is not a resident of that culture, but a visitor. Her position of authority
is different, too: she is invited to lead workshops in these places as an expert in soundscape
composition, an insider to the soundscape at the same time as she is an outsider to the
culture. I analyze this piece in relation to a recent presentation of Westerkamp's in which
she considers this doubled position of the soundscape recordist, both inside and outside the
soundscape. One of the responses to this work describes Westerkamp as being able to
move fluidly between time, space and cultures. This evocative description led me to
consider Westerkamp's work in this chapter in terms of Homi Bhabha's (1992)
formulation of the "time-lag" as a liminal space that encourages re-location and cultural
difference, and of Rosi Braidotti's (1994) concept of the figurative mode in the production
of nomadic subjects. Westerkamp creates a liminal space by transforming sounds to evoke
both the place represented as well as a range of other related places, encouraging the
listener to listen to the place of recording and link it to memories of other places in their
own experience. "In the Studio" includes an introduction
to how Westerkamp created Gently Penetrating. This multimedia presentation includes
imagery from the place represented in the composition as well as computer score fragments
linked to sound files, accompanied by Westerkamp's comments about her use of each file
in the resulting composition, and its relationship to the context of the sound environment.
In the conclusions, Chapter Eleven, I consider in what ways this dissertation works as a
situated conversation, between composer, researcher, and listeners, and in what ways the
conversation has hardly begun. Part of this discussion will focus on how I am presenting
this dialogue, the means I have chosen. I was drawn to a hybrid form, part text and part
hyper-text, because of the ability of hypertext to present images and sound
with text, and because of its potential for intersubjective interactivity. While computer
technologies are well known for their ability to create completely imaginary, competitive
virtual environments such as video games, they are also becoming known for their function
as social arenas encouraging communication over distance and interaction that goes beyond
the mouse-click to engage "conscious agencies in conversation, playfully and
spontaneously developing a mutual discourse."21 Current research in what Rosi Braidotti22
calls "cyberfeminism" suggests some approaches used by feminists to construct virtual
environments that are situated and intersubjective. These range from new approaches to
video games,23 multimedia performance,24 and interactions through the internet,25 which
attempt to encourage intersubjectivity through the format of the presentation as well as
connections to places and conversations with people beyond the confines of the computer.
The multimedia format gives people access to materials such as colour imagery and music
that are not usually available in a written dissertation, as well as scores, music analysis,
bibliography, discography, footnotes and so on, with choices about how these are
presented. In my website, I employ hypertext links to related academic and artistic internet
sites, for up-to-date information and connections to organizations such as the World Forum
for Acoustic Ecology. Visitors to the site are invited to converse with me through email
links on the site. At the same time, I have often chosen to use more traditional forms of
writing in order to pay attention to practical concerns (wanting to read sometimes away
from a computer screen, for instance). The conclusions will consider interactivity in the
hybrid form of the dissertation, in the developing relationship between Westerkamp and
myself, and in the listener responses.
1 On the program Dr. Who. After thirty years, I can still hear it. I wasn't aware at that time that the music
for this British TV show was composed by Tristram Cary, an electroacoustic composer who is perhaps
better known in the electroacoustic world for his work on the VCS3 or Putney synthesizer (Chadabe 1997:
53-54; 150-152).
2 Oliveros, Pauline. "The Music and Soundscapes of Hildegard Westerkamp." Transformations CD liner
notes. MontrŸal: DIFFUSION i MŸDIA, 1996, 18.
3 Especially in difficult weather: "In fog, mist, falling snow or heavy rainstorms, whether by day or by
night, the signals described in this Article shall by used" (The International Regulations for Preventing
Collisions at Sea Article 15, paragraph 4. This set of regulations is known colloquially to seamen as the
Rules of the Road at Sea and was adopted by the International Convention for the Safety of Life at Sea
(SOLAS) in 1929). Mariners would listen to fog horns, ships' sirens and echoes to judge distances from
other vessels and the shoreline. Officers on sea-going vessels are expected to know all the rules. I am
grateful to my father, Capt. Jeffrey McCartney, for this information. As an officer and examiner of Masters
and Mates, he was expected to know these rules by heart and be able to quote them.
4 For example, Claude Debussy's La Mer, or R. Murray Schafer's Waves, which uses the timing of ocean
waves as a structural basis.
6 Acoustic ecology is the study of the relationship between living organisms and their sonic environment
or soundscape.The World Forum for Acoustic Ecology (WFAE), founded in Banff, Alberta in 1993, is an
international interdisciplinary coalition of individuals and institutions concerned with the state of the world
soundscape. The Canadian Association of Sound Ecology (CASE) is a regional affiliate of WFAE.
Westerkamp and I are founding members of both organizations.
7 For instance, Murray Schafer's A Sound Education, Indian River, Ontario: Arcana, 1992; and The
Thinking Ear, Indian River: Arcana, 1986.
8 For example Barry Truax' Acoustic Communication, Norwood, NJ: Ablex, 1984.
9 See for instance Schafer's and Westerkamp's contributions to Sound By Artists, Banff AB: Walter
Phillips, 1990; and Westerkamp's contribution to Radio Rethink: Art, Sound and Transmission, Banff, AB:
Walter Phillips, 1994.
10 The most obvious example here is Schafer's well-known The Tuning of the World, Toronto: McClelland
and Stewart, 1977. There were many other publications produced as a result of the work of the World
Soundscape Project; however Schafer's large volume is the best known internationally, having been
translated into several different languages.
11 Truax, Barry. Acoustic Communication. Ablex: Norwood, NJ, 1984. This book, primarily concerned
with an acoustic approach to communication studies, has a chapter on electroacoustic composition.
Soundscape composition is discussed within that section. The more recent "Soundscape, Acoustic
Communication and Environmental Sound Composition" (1996) focuses specifically on soundscape work
at Simon Fraser University in relationship to contemporary composition.
12 An approach to working with recorded sounds developed by Pierre Schaeffer in Paris shortly after WW II.
Later work by this studio became known as acousmatic music.
13 An approach developed by composers working at the Cologne studio in the early 1950s, using
electrically-produced sounds composed according to the serial method.
14 See for instance Citron (1993) for a discussion of the construction of generic norms in Western art
music; McClary (1991) for a brief discussion of the norms of electroacoustic music in relation to the work
of performance artist Laurie Anderson.
15 I use the word 'place' here advisedly. Westerkamp says that she wants to transport her audience to a place
when they listen.
16 I have expanded this soundwalk site to include more recent soundwalks that I have done at sound art
festivals in Kitchener, Ontario, and Chicago, Illinois. The site was recently selected to be part of the Maid
in Cyberspace Encore online exhibition curated by Studio XX in MontrŸal.
17 This resulted in a show at the Eleanor Winters Gallery at York University, a video installation at the
Kitchen in New York City as part of the Music from Nature festival, and a show at the Modern Fuel
Gallery in Kingston, Ontario.
18 I have published an article about these projects and the influence of Westerkamp on my compositional
style: "Soundwalk in the Park with Hildegard Westerkamp," Musicworks 72, Fall 1998: 6-15, with music
excerpts from the installation on the accompanying CD.
19Breathing Room. "’lectroclips." 1990. MontrŸal: empreintes DIGITALes. CD. DIFFUSION i MŸDIA.
The producers asked each composer to create a piece under three minutes in length that encapsulated his or
her musical style.
20 This is the same piece that is the basis of the "In the Studio" section of the CD ROM.
21Allucqu‰re, Rosanne Stone. "Sex, Death and Machinery Or How I Fell In Love With My Prosthesis."
The War of Desire and Technology at the Close of the Mechanical Age. Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press,
1995: 11.
22 Braidotti, Rosi. "Cyberfeminism with a difference."
http://www.let.ruu.nl/somwnes_studies/rosi/cyberfem.htm. Accessed February 7, 1997, 5:25 pm. Last
modified: July 3, 1996.
23 See, for instance, Sanders, Toby. "Boys and Girls Take to Oregon Trail II." Global Navigator Inc.
http://gnn.com/gnn/meta/edu/features/archive/ot2.html. Accessed March 7, 1996; Koch, Melissa.
"Education Center: No Girls Allowed!" Global Navigator Inc.
http://www.gnn.com/gnn/meta/edu/features/archive/gtech.html. Accessed March 14, 1996; Favre, Gregory.
"Logged On or Left Out? Women and Computers: A Sacramento Bee special report." The Sacramento Bee
online. http://www.nando.net/sacbee/women/ Accessed March 14, 1996; Cassell, Justine. Personal
homepage: "Justine Cassell." http://justine.www.media.mit.edu/people/justine/. Accessed March 7, 1996.
24 Recent multimedia performances by myself and Selena Cryderman define interactivity not merely by the
inclusion of mouse-clicks but by mutual discourse between the performers. See for instance
http://www.finearts.yorku.ca/selena/sonic.html. Also, see the discussion of interactivity in Allucqu‰re
1995: 10ff.
25 Keng Chua. "Gender and the Web." AusWeb '95.
http://www.scu.edu.au/ausweb95/papers/sociology/chua/. Accessed March 6, 1996; Lawley, Elizabeth
Jane. "Computers and the Communication of Gender." 1995. http://www.itcs.com/elawley/gender.html.
Accessed March 6, 1996.